Based
off of the 1976 film of the same name, The Bad News Bears
is yet another slender summer remake that’s only real
breath of freshness is the performance by Billy Bob Thornton.
The film is
directed by the very straightforward, yet talented filmmaker
Richard Linklater, who seems to have a terrific balance
between his studio (School of Rock) and his indie projects
(Before Sunset). The film is predictable and similar to
the original, which finds a one time baseball player, now
drunk womanizer named Morris Buttermaker (Thornton), who
takes on a band of troublemaking and foul-mouthed little
leaguers and turns them into a real team, sort of.
With the help
of a local lawyer (Marcia Gay Harden), Buttermaker who is
a full time pest control worker becomes the coach of a team
of misfit kids just for the paycheck. The kids are all foul-mouthed
and each troubled by certain issues. One has angry problems,
one is overweight, two can’t speak English, one is
shy, and even one is handicapped. At first Buttermaker does
not care at all about the kids, he brings them along to
help him kill rats and passes out drunk on the pitching
mound while throwing batting practice. The Bears team of
course has a rival with the league’s best team, the
Yankees. The Yankees stubborn coach,Roy Bullock (Greg Kinnear),
also develops a hated relationship with Buttermaker. However
as terrible as the Bears are, the more time they spend with
one another, the more they solidify as a team. In need of
additional help, Buttermaker recruits the flame-throwing
daughter of an ex-flame to pitch for the team and a slugging
juvenile to play shortstop. As with the original, the film
is rude and at times dark, but it does turn into a soul-searching
film for Buttermaker and each of the kids.
As with the
original Bad News Bears, this version exposes harsh behavior
with children continuously cursing, which merits its PG-13
rating. After a while, the cursing just becomes repetitive,
and nothing close to shocking. What does keep this film
afloat is Billy Bob Thornton himself. It is as if his character
of Morris Buttermaker knows a lot about baseball and is
the semi-kinder brother of his character from Bad Santa.
Thornton just has a wonderful comedic balance with his delivery
of each of his lines, which are so demeaning that one can
not help but laugh. His performance never seems artificial,
even with his change of heart during the second half of
the film.
Director Richard
Linklater worked from a script that was co-written by the
writers of Bad Santa, so it seem they are in tune with Thornton’s
tactics. The script is so predictable in nature that the
film’s serves as nothing fresh, except for its performances.
The characters each have their moments, but there are explanations
that are touched on, but never fulfilled, such as the questioning
of if Buttermaker is the pitcher Amanda’s father,
or what was his real history with her mother. There is even
a moment in the film where Amanda says that her mother is
coming to a game, but nothing ever evolves from this one
line.
Linklater knows
how to work with kids; he proved that with School of Rock.
He gets the goods out of his kids in this film as well,
but the script just lacks the bit of spark and originality
that made School of Rock so entertaining. As with most of
Linklater’s choices, the whole film is very simple,
to where there is nothing terribly horrible with this film,
but nothing extravagant either. The Bad News Bears is at
times funny, but it is not a laugh fest.
It is a shame
that The Bad News Bears is just another one of those summer
remakes that studios seem to keep revisiting. This film
has the spirit of the original, but not the spontaneity
or genuineness. It is really worth seeing just for Thornton’s
performance, which is like a PG-13 version of his outstanding
work in the dark comedy Bad Santa.