Coach Carter Movie Review:


Towering above everything and everyone else, Samuel L. Jackson owns the screen in “Coach Carter.” His intense, dynamic presence lifts this film above the usual sports movie and makes it one to remember. Jackson immerses himself completely in the role of Ken Carter, a real coach who taught his high school basketball team there are more important things in life than winning a game.

“I had a very short list of actors who I’d like to see portray me,” says Carter. “Samuel L. Jackson was the only name on it.” After seeing this film, I know why.

Facing hostile parents, uncooperative teachers and the wrath of the community, Carter refused to let his winning 1999 Richmond High Oilers (a team including his own son) play any more games until they lived up to the contract they signed -- an agreement to maintain a 2.30 grade point average, attend class regularly and sit in the front row. Carter even padlocked the gym to make sure no basketball activities could take place. And he told his players to meet him in – shock – the library. “Where is the library?” asks one surprised student.

“My idea was to substitute books for balls – as simple as that,” Carter explains. Defending his reasoning behind the controversial contract, Carter says the document was used to prevent players from falling through the cracks and to make them responsible for their future

“This is definitely not your typical story and Ken Carter is not your typical guy,” Jackson declares. “Both the story and Ken are about teaching young people to expect more from themselves and to see beyond their present.”

As a former teacher and school administrator, I applaud the important message of this movie, but I’m skeptical about its depiction of teachers as reluctant to give progress reports on the team members in their classes because “It’s too much extra work.” In my experience, most teachers would be happy to help students improve their academic work, especially school athletes.

My only other quibble about the film involves its anti-climactic last basketball match. The rest of the games are exciting to watch, thanks to Mark Ellis of Reel Sports who served as the movie’s basketball coordinator. “These kids worked nonstop for months to ensure the believability of the game sequences and I believe all their hard work and practice really paid off,” Ellis declares.

Directed by Thomas Carter, who’s no relation to Ken Carter, “Coach Carter” depicts the players’ home environment as realistically as the basketball sequences. In 1999, the Richmond, California, area concerned was a run-down, low income community – and the movie definitely gave me a feeling of “being there.”

Kudos also to the young actors portraying Coach Carter’s diverse group of team members. Rob Brown (“Finding Forrester”) stands out as a key player conflicted about his girlfriend’s (Ashanti) pregnancy, and Rich Gonzalez (“Biker Boyz”) is immensely watchable as the “tough guy” seduced by peer pressure and the drug culture.

Because it takes on so many educational and social issues, “Coach Carter” is an extremely ambitious film. And that’s probably exactly what the real Ken Carter wanted.

Betty Jo Tucker

Since it's based on a true story, we can forgive the filmmakers their heartwarming excesses. This is a thoroughly entertaining film, but you do wish they'd tell the tale without funnelling it through Hollywood's inspirational movie assembly line.

Ken Carter (Jackson) didn't need the job when he was offered the chance to coach the losing basketball team at Richmond High School, on the rough innercity side of San Francisco Bay (although filmed amid L.A.'s palm trees). Basketball is all these students live for, but Carter knows there are some things more important than sport. Even after winning over most of the players--and creating a winning team--he finds strong resistance in the school and community. So he takes drastic action.

The painfully obvious script wastes no time setting up each expected conflict. The characters are engaging, but only slightly more than stereotypes. Jackson barely breaks a sweat to play Carter's tough-love coach; he's almost too nice as the guy willing to break the system to help the kids. As his players, Brown (Finding Forrester) is the standout as a conflicted and intelligent young man with a pregnant girlfriend (Ashanti) and difficult decisions to make. Ri'chard is very good as Carter's determined son; Gonzalez handles the fiery tough-guy Latino role well; and Tanner, Gbewonyo and Tatum give nicely edgy performances as the smart-mouthed charmer, challenged student and tough white homie, respectively.

But the cliched script often leaves them floundering with its tame locker room antics, threats of drug/gang violence and constant touching moments. Director Carter (no relation) films the games energetically, but features so many shots of the scoreboard (and so many last-second slo-mo clips) that they become a new cliche all their own. At least he gets the first "captain, my captain!" scene out of the way early on. And avoids rah-rah halftime pep talks.

It also helps that the film's based on real events, which gives it the authenticity its superficial script lacks. There are extremely important issues lurking in here that seriously need examining, and while the film sidesteps the story's true grit, it at pushes all the emotional buttons right on cue.

Rich Cline

 

Site Contents Copyright© The Z Review, unless used with permission.This site has no intention to infringe on the rights of the film owners of Coach Carter and intellectual copyright holders of the movies mentioned herein & hold copyright over the movie, characters, merchandise & storyline.