Dawn
of the Dead Movie Review:
One of
the recent Hollywood trends is to “re-envision,”
not remake, a classic cult horror film for the new generation
of moviegoers. The latest entry in this “re-envision”
movement is Dawn of the Dead, based off George A. Romero’s
1979 original zombie chiller. Close to the film’s
only strength, is the shot selection by first time feature
director Zach Snyder. Unfortunately, Dawn of the Dead’s
numerous inconsistencies and brusque problems has this film
coming nowhere close to being a classic “zombie”
flick.
The
hinted unleashing of the film’s zombies comes that
when hell fills up, the dead will walk the earth. The flesh-hungry
zombies move chaotically quick (like the zombies in 28 Days
Later) in a raged mode and once a being is bitten, shortly
they will join the zombie clan. The film’s first zombies
appear in pursuit of a dedicated nurse named Ana (Sarah
Polley) in her suburban Wisconsin home. After narrowly escaping
her suburb and the apocalyptic chaos of the city, she teams
up with a handful of human survivors. The group includes
a hard-nosed cop (Ving Rhames), a salesman that continuously
comes up with problem-solving ideas (Jake Weber), a street-wise
soon to be dad (Mekhi Phifer), and his pregnant wife. The
group make their way into an abandoned shopping mall and
discover human conflicts from the mall’s security
unit headed by CJ (Michael Kelly). The mall is put on lockdown
as the survivors attempt to figure out what has happened
and what does the future hold. The zombies themselves are
huddled around the mall by the thousands and through the
last minutes of emergency television broadcasting, the survivors
learn that the zombies can only be killed by a shot to the
head or fire. After a few more survivors arrive, the group
has to fight off occasional zombies that squander into the
mall as well as battle zombie transformations among themselves
after being bitten. Though disagreement and continuos arguing
comprises the survivors, each is driven to cherish their
humanity and implement a basis of subsistence if they want
to remain alive.
This
film is of course driven by continuos jump out moments and
gallons of blood and chunky gore. The zombies themselves
make roaring sounds as if they are werewolves more than
are the undead. As mentioned previously, this film’s
zombie movements are reminiscent of Danny Boyle’s
athletic and extremely fast choices in 28 Days Later. Director
Zack Snyder shows flashes of promise, but the overabuance
of inconsistencies and amateurish moments stoops this film
down to the depths of monstrous. The editing is really appalling
and the script does not fare much better. At first it seems
that five seconds after being bitten or dying, that person
becomes a zombie. As the film progresses, it seems that
the bitten become zombies once the film needs them to be,
or if there has been over five minutes without a shot involving
gore or blood. One obvious inconsistency is that though
the mall is lockdowned by the security unit, Ana and the
survivors entrance is never shown. Also, after a initial
defeat of many zombies in the mall’s open parking
garage, the humans just go back into the garage to build
their artillery buses without seeing a single zombie, though
thousands are banging on the mall’s outer doors. These
are really just nit-picky things that stick out, besides
the insipid notions in the screenplay by James Gunn. There
is also no balance of being serious or “campy,”
with this horror film, it seems that the script goes back
and forth. Humorously, some of the dead serious notions
deliver the film’s worse dialogue, such as Sarah Polley’s
line of “Michael is coming to kill you,” to
one of the bitten survivors.
Mostly
an independent film actress, Polley herself is suitable
as the film’s heroine nurse Ana. Ving Rhames delivers
a performance we have seen before, but is still admirable.
Most of the cast as well as the characters are wooden, but
for a film of this nature, acting is not the top priority.
In fact, it is better to have flimsy acting in a zombie
film.
Though
not as terrible as other recent horror films like Freddy
vs. Jason or Jeepers Creepers 2, Dawn of the Dead is still
nothing close to pertinent as film of this genre. It seems
if the film would have had a little more balance of cheese
and serious notions, and a lot more consistency, it could
have been a cult classic or at least a fun guilty pleasure.
Grade:
C-
Joseph
Tucker
A
plague is spreading, killing millions in its wake but it
doesn’t stop there. Once an infected person is dead,
they return to life as flesh hungry, homicidal killers.
As the world falls into hell, a group of survivors hold
out in a shopping mall but it won’t be long before
the hordes of undead come looking for fresh meat.
As original
ideas continue to elude Hollywood, they return again to
the horror archives and update a classic of the genre, George
A. Romero’s Dawn of the Dead.
As the
sound of zombie’s stirring in their graves greets
this news, the undead can return to their eternal rest,
as the movie isn’t the travesty that it so easily
could have been. This is blood soaked, head splattering,
flesh eating horror entertainment and has everything a good
zombie flick should have. The killings are gruesome, the
undead are deadly and everyone of the cast has an equal
chance of dying. What more do you want from a horror flick?
The
cast make the movie what it is. The excellent Sarah Polly
proves again that she is an actress to watch. This is a
very natural performance from her which makes Ana a very
believeable character. She reacts to the situation as you’d
expect people to but she is never too overly dramatic or
foolhardy. Ving Rhames is as good as ever with another commanding
performance as no nonsense police officer Kenneth. This
is a man you would want with you in a crisis. Jake Webber
is one of those actors that you always recognise and can
never put a name to. Hopefully this movie will push him
more into the limelight. Mekhi Phifer does well with his
small but important role. The support is also good but most
of them are just potential food for the slaughter.
A lot
of the plaudits have to go to first time director Zack Snyder.
He paces the movie extremely well throwing in shock after
shock at a relentless rate. He hardly ever telegraphs any
of his scares, with zombie and killings coming from every
conceivable standpoint putting you on the edge of your seat
throughout. The look of the movie is also very good with
fast cuts and quick reveals making it all the more frightening.
The
film is not without its problems however. Firstly this isn’t
a movie that needed to be remade and it will struggle to
grab the attention of purists and Romero fans alike. The
film also misses the main point of the original, man’s
obsession with commercialism to the point that they would
return to the hub of that addiction, the shopping mall,
even in death. Finally the overly energetic zombies are
a complete rip off from Danny Boyle’s 28 Days Later
but this does increase the menace of the masses of flesh-hungry
undead.
Dawn
of the Dead is a blood soaked, late night horror flick that
is extremely entertaining, even if it does steal all its
ideas. It might bring nothing new to the genre but this
a fright fest that is still a cut above most of the current
horror flicks that Hollywood has turning out of late.
Star
Rating = * * *
Jamie
Kelwick
There
are staples of a genre and then there are the immortals.
George A. Romero’s 1968 classic “Night of the
Living Dead” is still one of the greatest horror films
of all time. It still holds its own and scares the pants
off you with each viewing. It is eternal.
Ten
years after that classic, Romero awakened our fears once
more with “Dawn of the Dead”. To some people
this film is the pinnacle of zombie films and something
not to be messed with. That is where my fears came from
when I heard they were remaking it. Romero later completed
his zombie trilogy with 1985’s “Day of the Dead”.
Those
three films were some of the best horror films made in each
of those decades. Less than a month after the release of
“Day” the zombie genre took a horrible turn.
In August of 1985, a new kind of zombie movie was born.
The film was “Return of the Living Dead” which
took a lot of what Romero cherished and turned it on its
ear by adding a goofy soundtrack, sub-standard heroes and
comedic elements. The film was a hit and spawned 2 sequels.
The comedy and gore delighted audiences but nearly killed
the pure horror of the zombie.
In 1990,
Hollywood revisited Romero’s 1968 classic with an
incredibly interesting and fear ridden remake. It was an
amazing attempt at trying to recapture the fear that Romero
thrived in. The film thrived from incredible performances
by unknown actors like Tony Todd (who would later become
“Candy Man”) and Patricia Tallman (who would
later become a regular on “Babylon 5”). It wasn’t
as insanely clever, horrific or bold as the original but
it was an amazing achievement and seemed to honor more than
dismay the Romero classic.
That
brings us to 2004 and Hollywood ventures back into Romero
territory as it remakes the second in the classic trilogy.
Medical
nurse Ana Clark (Sarah Polley) awakens one morning to see
her world turned upside down. She is forced to flee her
home when her husband Luis (Justin Louis) becomes infected
with an unknown contagion which he seems to have contracted
from a neighbor’s young girl.
Ana
is wrought with horror, shock and bewilderment as she drives
away from her home. Eventually Ana reunites with survivors
Kenneth (Ving Rhames), Michael (Jake Weber), Andre (Mekhi
Phifer) and his pregnant wife who are also enduring the
ordeal of the outbreak.
The
ragtag fugitives take refuge in a fortress of glass or to
others a huge suburban mall. There they learn about what
has happened, who each of them are and eventually plot an
escape from the mob of growing zombies.
The
2004 version of “Dawn of the Dead” opens strongly
and we are quickly captivated by the wrought but strong
performance of Sarah Polley. Sadly her character seems to
be the only one we really get to know.
Polley’s
supporting characters excluding Ving Rhames and Jake Weber
range from “cannon-fodder” to “red-neck”
to annoying. I just wanted them all to be gobbled up by
the mob. If these are the last of humanity please let us
be wiped out.
That
is kind of sad to say when capable actors like Mekhi Phifer,
Matt Frewer, Lindy Booth and Jayne Eastwood are among them.
Phifer has his moments but he seems terminal from his introduction
and Frewer doesn’t stick around long enough.
If I
were to classify this version of a Romero classic I would
have to say that it in-between “Return of the Living
Dead” and the 1990 remake. It isn’t by far in
the same territory as anything done by Romero but as apocalypse/zombie
films it would be a fun matinee movie. Last year’s
“28 Days Later” was a far superior horror film
than this.
Here’s
the Great Zombie Breakdown:
Night
of the Living Dead 1968 (5 out of 5)
Dawn
of the Dead 1978 (4.5 out of 5)
Day
of the Dead 1985 (4 out of 5)
Return
of the Living Dead 1985 (3 out of 5)
Return
of the Living Dead Part 2 1988 (2 out of 5)
Return
of the Living Dead Part 3 (1.5 out of 5)
Night
of the Living Dead 1990 (4 out of 5)
Dawn
of the Dead 2004 (3.5 out of 5)
What’s
your favorite zombie movie?
So Says
the Soothsayer
Dean Kish
Not
so much a remake of George A Romero's 1978 classic as a
recycling of the premise, this action-packed zombie flick
certainly keeps our adrenalin pumping. After a brief scene
of urban normality in Milwaukee, it rockets into chaos and
carries us shrieking and laughing along. The filmmakers
don't waste time with explanations; the world is simply
turned upside down one morning when a nurse named Ana (Polley)
wakes up to find herself on the run from crowds of hungry,
vicious and very tenacious undead. She takes refuge with
a group of survivors in a shopping mall-- tough cop (Rhames),
reluctant leader (Weber), protective father-to-be (Phifer)
with hugely pregnant wife (Korobkina), womaniser (Kelly),
trio of over-zealous security guards (Kelly, Zegers and
Barry). A few others join them as they try to find a way
out ... and news about the outside world. And these aren't
standard staggering, dazed zombies--they run and leap and
bite at lightning speed.
There's
a thrilling, off-handed style to this film that really grabs
the imagination. Inventive camerawork and effects and clever
editing add to witty touches at every turn, from the hilarious
choice of background muzak to cynical, sardonic dialog that's
never knowing or silly, but rather the things real people
say in incredibly tense situations. Led by the superb Polley,
the cast is excellent, each person facing the horrific reality
in their own way and showing humanity in all its glory,
for better or worse. The script is full of clever touches
and an underlying sense of morbid humour, but it also shies
away from making significant comments on the religious or
social themes it tries to raise. The direction and editing
only falter in their over-reliance on false starts and red
herrings, as well as some severe jump cuts that skip key
bits of logic and leave us momentarily furious at such lazy
filmmaking. But we don't have much time to be annoyed before
the next bit of mayhem takes our breath away again.
Rich
Cline
Site
Contents Copyright© The Z Review, unless used with permission.This
site has no intention to infringe on the rights of the film
owners of Dawn of the Dead and intellectual copyright holders of the
movies mentioned herein & hold copyright over the movie,
characters, merchandise & storyline.