To follow
up his masterful The Twilight Samurai (2002), Yamada tells
another tale of everyday life during the waning years of
samurai society. It's beautifully observed, with strong
characters and a lovely romantic plot, although it's as
a bit too subdued.
Munezo
(Nagase) is a low-level samurai who's never drawn his sword
and is in love with the sparky Kie (Matsu), from the wrong
caste and therefore impossible to consider as a wife. When
a friend (Ozawa) is involved in a rebellion against the
Westernisation of the Japanese forces, Munezo is ordered
by his boss (Ogata) to sort it out. So Munezo revisits his
old sensei (Tanaka) to find out how to engage in a real
battle to the death, and to remember the secret of the hidden
blade.
The
story is rich and layered, with evocative interaction between
the characters. Even if the time and culture are alien to
us, we identify with these people. And the pressure to Westernise
with guns instead of swords is both fascinating and eerily
relevant (the new teacher complains bitterly about these
"stupid, back-country samurai"--"Don't stop
to bow when you're loading a cannon!"). Performances
are raw and natural, as the characters tease each other
mercilessly, try to balance honour against betrayal and
attempt to find happiness within a restrictive society.
Yamada
beautifully avoids the flowery density of most period dramas
for a more authentic design. The story is similarly organic,
resisting Western structures to find a real story that has
moments of incredible action and romance, but not when we
expect them. And certainly not how we expect the scenes
to play out. Nothing is heightened at all--it's played out
in a way that feels utterly true.
And
this risky approach is also a weakness, because we're so
conditioned to narrative drive that the film feels rather
lifeless. But it's worth sticking with for a remarkably
faithful, unadorned story that's thoughtful and funny, insightful
and powerfully moving. The intense personal dilemmas are
strongly sympathetic, the action is pure and unforced, and
the romance rolls along at a wonderfully unfussy pace. Gorgeous.