The Last Samurai Review:
“The Last Samurai” surely has everything that one would expect from an epic film, such as intense battle sequences, stylish sword fights, heroism, love, and honor. However, the film's centralities are its human and cultural aspects, and director Edward Zwick does a masterful job of telling this epic story.
The film takes place a few years after the Civil War, and finds Captain Nathan Algren (Tom Cruise) as a depressed drunk that is out of luck and money. Though a renowned war figure, the horrors of war, which include the slaughtering of Native Americans, have left Algren without much left to live for. His life is changed, when he is given a proposal for his expertise that will pay him five-hundred dollars a month. His new job consists of him going to Japan to train the emperor's soldiers in the art of war by American standards, which includes arterially and strategy. Japan at the time is a society that is leaving behind its heritage to become more Western, also know as Pragmatism. Once arriving in the foreign land, Algren learns of the Japanese's current enemy, which are their own Samurai soldiers led by the great warrior Katsumoto (Ken Wantabe). The Samurai reject Japan 's Western change and want to maintain their values and way of life, by any means necessary. As Algren continues to learn of the revolt by the Samurai soldiers, he is ordered to go into battle with many untrained men. Pleading that the soldiers are not ready, the army is ambushed by the Samurai warriors and in the process Algren is captured by Katsumoto and taken prisoner to a hidden community.
Katsumoto does not kill Algren, due to the fact that he wants to know his enemy, and what he is teaching the Japanese army. Wounded and rattled, Algren becomes frustrated with Katsumoto's many conversations of war, by constantly yelling, “What do you want from me?” Over the next months, Algren is taken care of by the Katsumoto's beautiful sister, Taka (Koyuki), whom he widowed by taking the life of her husband in battle. Algren is placed in a different setting, a different culture, and begins to understand the Samurai's way of life, which consist of courage, honor, and loyalty. The unlikely friendship between Katsumoto and Algren develops, and the American Captain begins to find his identity within the peaceful and compassionate culture.
Edward Zwick, who has previously directed the superb films “Glory” and “Legends of the Fall,” delivers another great one with “The Last Samurai.” The film is beautifully shot by Zwick and the great cinematographer John Toll (“Legends of the Fall,” “Braveheart”). The beautiful landscapes and colors of Japan are vividly presented. The battle sequences are powerfully captured, to where the chaos is felt, but the violence is never overblown. The sword fight scenes are also a treat to watch. As mention previously, the human aspects and levels of the film are what rises above all else, and Zwick maintains its consistency through out the film. The clashing and acceptance of values are realistically revealed as well. An example is that it takes time for Algren to learn the Japanese language; he does not just learn it over a few days. There are some scenes in the film that are reflective reenactments of Zwick's previous choices in “Glory,” but the choices work in this film nonetheless. Hans Zimmer also delivers a vibrant and striking score to contribute to the film's quality and feel.
Zwick also co-wrote the film with two other writers, including “Gladiator” scribe John Logan. The script works significantly as a blueprint for the film's exhibition and sequencing. There are aspects in the script that could have been really cliché, like the quiet villain with a birth mark on his cheek or the perceived winks at treasonism and epiphanies. Though some of the aspects in the finale of the film go a little overboard, the script never really falters, it maintains composure and overall is pretty well conceived.
Tom Cruise delivers a courageous performance as Captain Nathan Algren. Though not the best of his career by any means, Cruise is still shows his range as a movie star that is actually a fine actor as well. As Katsamoto, Ken Watanabe delivers the film's boldest performance with his wonderful tactics and demanding facial gestures. Watanabe might be mention in the category of Best Supporting Actor this Oscar season for his performance. The rest of the cast serve their purpose well, which includes the beautiful Koyuki as Taka, the great Billy Connolly as Algren's close friend, and Tony Goldwyn as an egotistical commanding officer.
“The Last Samurai” is very similar to Kevin Costner's “Dances with Wolves” in a lot of ways, especially with the cultural aspects. The feel of the film itself is similar to other epics such as “Braveheart” and “Rob Roy.” This is a very entertaining film that could very well receive numerous award nominations. Edward Zwick has woven together another engaging and impressive film. “The Last Samurai” is one of the best films of the year.
Grade: A
12/05/03
By Joseph C. Tucker
Who
and what were the illustrious Japanese warriors known as
“samurai”? What were their ideals, who did they
protect and who did they wage endless battle against?
Furthermore,
where did they go? It is that final question that looked
at in the feature film, “The Last Samurai”.
Captain
Nathan Algren (Tom Cruise) is a haunted man. A Civil War
veteran, Nathan chronicles his life and experiences for
profit but his war demons sit promptly on his shoulders.
Those demons unlock a horrific event housed within Nathan.
Nathan’s demons have brought him disgrace and failure
until he is confronted by one of the men linked to Nathan’s
demons, Colonel Bagley (Tony Goldwyn).
Bagley
brings a disgraced Nathan to meet some prestigious men who
have journeyed from Japan. The men want an American war
hero to help train and arm their troops as they wage war
on some rather brutal rebels. In a drunken stupor, Nathan
agrees.
Nathan
is whisked off to Japan where he finds that there are two
worlds within the evolving Japanese society. A lot of these
ways reflect highly upon Nathan and his experiences as an
officer.
How
will this distant land affect a lost man like Nathan? Who
are these rebels known as “samurai”? And how
will Nathan make it home alive when confronted by them?
The
best way to describe the “Last Samurai” is that
it’s an amalgamation of “Dances With Wolves”
and “Glory” but set in Japan. The script writers
and director Edward Zwick, who uncannily directed “Glory”,
have found a way into the world of the samurai without forcing
away the audience. We learn, understand and feel for these
people as we pull back the curtain to see the way they once
were.
Casting
Tom Cruise is actually a good thing for this film because
we need someone so out of place and alien to the world so
that we can experience it through his eyes. It is always
nice to have a “tour guide” character in a historical
epic. The reason being is that it’s hard for modern
thinkers to relate to times without modern conveniences.
I liked how Cruise brought some of his Oscar-nominated “Born
on the Fourth of July” performance to his incarnation
of Algren. Just like his character in “Born”,
this character is betrayed by war and frustrated at his
over-seers. Cruise develops a raw intensity and it works
well against the controlled and methodical “bushido”
code of the samurai.
The
relationship between Algren and the Japanese mother, Taka
(Koyuki), was wonderfully laid out. The filmmakers resisted
the temptation of a tumultuous relationship between the
characters. It is almost a poetry of eyes and unspoken thoughts.
It is beautiful, eloquent and so memorable.
Probably
one of the most amazing parts of this film is the attention
to detail that was paid in carving out the rural “samurai”
village and crowded 18th Century Tokyo streets. The tiniest
little detail is paid in each frame of the film.
“The
Last Samurai” is probably the best film about westerners
and the samurai since the epic landmark mini-series “Shogun”.
There is a lot of homage here and it often took me back
to that series. The battle sequences and restructuring of
the Japanese world years after the events in “Shogun”
make “Samurai” stand on its own.
I love
the epic feel of feudal Japan and the history of the lost
traditions. On a personal level that is probably why I loved
this film so much. I did however find a couple flaws in
its depiction. The film’s ending feels tacked on and
it so takes away from the majesty of a lot of moments housed
within the film. I am not sure all of it was necessary.
Well
what happened to the “samurai”? Like all great
things they were probably replaced with a microchip. But
it is safe to say that the bushido code does live and evolve
in a lot of us.
What do you think?
(4.75 out of 5)
Dean Kish
Writer-director
Zwick has a way with complex movies about bravery and honour
(Glory, Courage Under Fire), although he also tends to slightly
overcook the material (The Siege, Legends of the Fall).
This film brings out both tendencies in an entertaining
but uneven battle epic. By the mid-1870s, Nathan Algren
(Cruise) is a bitter veteran of the US Army's attempts to
subdue the Native American population. He accepts an offer
of work from the Japanese government, just to get away from
the demons that haunt him ... although he's still working
with his bloodthirsty commander (Goldwyn)! The new job is
to train and equip the army of the Emperor (Nakamura) to
suppress the Samurai rebellion, but it doesn't quite go
to plan. Soon Algren is captured by the Samurai lord Katsumoto
(Watanabe), who's curious about this tenacious, troubled
American. And as Algren begins to understand the Samurai
code of honour, he begins to find his real self.
There's
a terrific central story here that really draws us in, and
Cruise's strong performance engages us in Algren's quest.
As usual, Cruise throws himself headlong into the role--physically,
emotionally and dramatically--and even if it's a rather
self-conscious performance, it's some of his best work,
with moments of gut-wrenching drama and astonishing physicality
(he does all his own fighting and stuntwork). Watanabe is
excellent as his spiritual foil; supporting characters such
as the Samurai played by Sanada and Harada (and others)
are fascinating and very well-played; and the amazing Spall
shines in a small but key role. The film also looks amazing,
with spectacular New Zealand scenery standing in for 19th
century Japan. But Zwick's choices as a director are more
troublesome--the film is choppy and over-edited, even in
the quiet moments, with action scenes that rarely grab hold
simply because we can't see what's happening. And the script
refuses to immerse itself in the complexities of the culture,
continually defining everything in Western terms. At first
this echoes Algren's experience, but as he embraces the
Samurai ways, the film finds itself at odds with him. Depth
is only glimpsed in the complex emotions in the actors'
eyes; everything else is simplistic or muddled. And while
the film still has seriously powerful moments, it's never
as profound or telling--or as gripping or emotional or even
as sexy--as we know it could have been.
Rich
Cline
1876,
consumed by guilt over his actions during the military campaigns
against the Native Americans, Captain Nathan Algren (Cruise)
had taken to drink to numb his pain. Tales of his deeds
on the battlefield however, had spread as far as the orient
and the Emperor of Japan himself had requested that Algren
be recruited to train his troops in modern combat techniques.
The army was needed to quell a rebellion by samurai leader
Katsumoto (Watanabe), who though his country was becoming
too obsessed with western ideals at the cost of the old
traditions. When his newly trained troops are sent into
battle far too early, Algren is captured and taken prisoner
by the samurai but during his time in their custody he begins
to find redemption in their accent customs.
Honour
is the true essence of the way of the Samurai and filmmakers
behind The Last Samurai have treated the story of the 1877
rebellion with that very much in mind.
Director
and screenwriter Edward Zwick combines with Gladiator scribe
John Logan to bring us a movie filled with exhilarating
fight scenes, invigorating battles, captivating characters
and most importantly a story that is filled with respect.
This is film that pulls no punches in showing American’s
push for global industrial dominance and its wiliness to
arm a nation in exchange for an iron clad trade contract.
In fact the advancing wave of industrialisation is the real
villain of the piece, as the once great traditions of a
nation fall by the wayside under this inevitable assault.
Along with this march to be modern, the film showcases the
traditional ideals of the samurai’s way of life. Every
aspect of their lives, from their code of honour and training
to their religious beliefs are shown in respectful detail
making you understand why Captain Algren was drawn into
their world.
The
attention to historical detail echoes the respect given
to the themes. The set and costume designs are superb capturing
the time exactly make the whole production look very authentic.
From the Japanese army uniforms to the exquisitely recreated
samurai armour and the brilliant recreation of a tradition
village, the whole production is steeped in respect and
admiration of the era and the story they are trying to tell.
The
fighting and battle sequences are quite simply exhilarating
and the filmmakers stick with the modern philosophy of no-holds-barred,
authentically detailed re-enactment. The camera takes you
into the thick of the action and then pans out to show the
sheer spectacle of what is going on. As howitzer cannons
and Gatling guns pour down their flak and bullets onto the
charging samurai, you witness the dying embers of a soon
to be forgot age disappear before your very eyes. It is
heart wrenching and harrowing but you can help but feel
a sense of honour for these brave warriors.
Historical
accuracy, a good story and an astonishing look would be
nothing without great performances and The Last Samurai
is filled with them. First and foremost is Tom Cruise’s
best and most challenging role since Magnolia. While he
explored his darker side in that film and Vanilla Sky, this
movie is a whole different ball game for the actor. We all
know he can excel in the physical elements of the script
but it is the way is reveals the character’s mental
anguish over past deeds and his growing sense of self worth
that sets this performance apart from the rest. This is
a tour-de-force for Cruise, proving that he is a character
actor that you can take seriously and not just a megastar
paid to bring in the big opening. He seems to come into
his own with projects he feels passionate about as he did
with Magnolia and Born on the Fourth of July, where the
emphasis is the story or the character and not him.
Ken
Watanabe’s role of Katsumoto steals some of the limelight
from star however. This is a commanding performance from
the Japanese actor. Every time he graces the screen he grabs
your attention such is his presence. He oozes honour and
respect as the leader of the rebellion, pulled between loyalty
to his Emperor and the traditions he wants to live on.
Good
support comes from the every reliable Timothy Spall and
Tony Goldwyn. Both play their parts superbly, with Goldwyn’s
Colonel Bagley an instantly dislikeable thorn in Algren’s
side. Koyuki as Katsumoto’s bereaved sister Taka and
Hiroyuki Sanada as his second in command Ujio as also extremely
good in their roles, with the hostility between Ujio and
Algren been a highlight.
While
Edward Zwick and his team might have taken a few liberties
with history (the samurai revolt is real but an American
was never involved), this is still a riveting story that
emphasises Japanese culture more than just America wanting
to rewrite history. This is historical story telling mixed
with the pure spectacle of modern cinema at its very best
and you will end up wishing that all movies were made with
the same amount of honour and respect as The Last Samurai.
Star
Rating = * * * * *
Jamie
Kelwick
Site
Contents Copyright© The Z Review, unless used with permission.This
site has no intention to infringe on the rights of the film
owners of The Last Samurai and intellectual copyright holders of the
movies mentioned herein & hold copyright over the movie,
characters, merchandise & storyline.