This film is an insightful, provocative examination of terrorism, as well as a thoughtful look at the Palestine-Israel situation. It's also a crackling, entertaining dramatic thriller that everyone should see.
Said and Khaled (Nashef and Suliman) are happy-go-lucky buddies in the occupied West Bank, drifting from job to job without worrying too much. Said is interested in Suha (Azabal), daughter of a famous martyr. And then a friend (Hlehel) tells them they've been chosen for a suicide bomb mission in Tel Aviv. Suddenly their life becomes gravely serious as they grapple with the issues, face their doubts and embark on a mission that doesn't remotely go to plan.
Yes, this story is told from the PLO perspective, and it is definitely sympathetic to their cause. But the filmmakers take a deeply personal approach, and as a result they can probe political issues with an emotional resonance that avoids preachiness and vilification. Set alongside Spielberg's similarly themed Munich, this film feels much more engaging and perceptive, and also more suspenseful, since the situations feel strikingly real, photographed with documentary simplicity.
The actors are also raw and honest as warm-hearted, complicated guys whose life is interrupted by a higher cause. Their families and friends are oblivious, although Said's mother (Abbass) knows something's up. And their decision to go forward with the plan is wrenching--from "In one hour we'll be heroes, with God in heaven" to "Is there no other way?" We feel the situation of a people group asked to accept inferiority, not democracy. They have no choice but to respond with their own bodies, even though they know it won't actually change anything.
This simple, unadorned filmmaking gets into the minds and hearts of its characters without judging them. It's so plainly truthful that it forces us to accept the validity of their motivation even if we detest their actions. By presenting life's detailed banality, filmmaker Abu-Assad actually manages to say something new about a thorny situation. Add nervewracking suspense, gripping emotion and the subtle but clear statement that violence solves nothing and only provokes more revenge. It's a knotty, challenging knockout of a film.
Rich Cline
Given
the opportunity to ask just one question of a suicide bomber,
what would you most want to know? In “Paradise Now,”
director Hany Abu-Assad explores his own curiosity about
what makes someone decide that killing themselves for political
leverage is a better option than living. He doesn't necessarily
provide answers, but his disturbingly realistic portrait
of a pair of Palestinian suicide bombers undoubtedly opens
a serious dialogue.
The
film is set in the occupied West Bank where tit-for-tat
violence between Israelis and Palestinians has caused unbearable
hardship for citizens on both sides of the conflict. The
multinational crew actually filmed many of the scenes in
the occupied territories and even faced their own dangers
during filming. Israeli missile attacks were a daily occurrence
and the kidnapping of their location manager by an armed
Palestinian faction required the intervention of former
Palestinian Authority leader Yasser Arafat. The dangers
pay off in a huge way however as the viewer is given a frightening
first-hand sense of the gravitas of the situation. If a
film crew with its own security force isn't safe, imagine
the insecurity felt by the area's residents.
The
acting of Kais Nashef and Ali Suliman is superb throughout
the film and seems overtly realistic at times. That could
be partly due to what Abu-Assad admits involved placing
the actors in surroundings that frightened them so badly
there was no need to act anymore. Several scenes are filmed
on the actual premises where real-life suicide bombers planned
and prepped for their missions.
The
film opens with what might very well be the last 48 hours
of Said (Nashef) and Khaled (Suliman), two lifelong friends
who pass time by sipping tea, and smoking hookah pipes when
they're not slaving for peanuts in their crappy jobs as
car mechanics. The oppressive poverty and incessant rocket
attacks on the city of Nablus provide little opportunity
for making a living, much less for harboring dreams of bettering
oneself.
Said
and Khaled are eventually approached by friend Jamal (Amer
Hlehel) who informs them that their day has finally come.
As if the weight of the world has been lifted from their
shoulders, the two begin an eerie ritual that leads up to
the suicide-bombing mission they are to undertake in Tel
Aviv. Screenwriter Bero Beyer and director/co-screenwriter
Hany Abu-Assad take us into the nuts and bolts of the preparatory
phase of the mission. From the clandestine meetings in underground
basements where they film their martyr videos to what slightly
resembles Christ's last meal (or even that of a condemned
inmate before execution), Said and Khaled begin the process
of purification before their mission. A morbid sense of
humor and pathos tinges the drama as Said and Khaled are
interrupted by a camera malfuntion while filming their martyr
videos. Abu-Assad admits mimicking reality with this scene
in that there's often comedy in the most tragic of real-life
moments.
That
Abu-Assad and his crew were allowed to film in the political
hotbed of the West Bank is a testament to his unbiased treatment
of the politics of his film. He's not choosing sides, nor
is he trying to sway the viewer. He simply wants to open
a meaningful discussion about the real issues at hand. Although
the full-scale weight of the Middle East situation seems
far too massive to show in one film, Abu-Assad manages to
bring a sense of sympathy and understanding to the senselessness
of the entire situation. He proves that neither side can
claim moral victory because taking any life is not a moral
action.
What
drives a suicide bomber to commit his act of terror? Generations
of poverty and hopelessness with no real sense of amelioration.