The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants Movie Review:


As a practicing movie addict, I’ll view practically anything that flickers. However, “The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants” is such a horrible title that I almost missed seeing this little gem of a movie. Yes, I know the Ann Brashares’ novel of the same name earned quite a following and became a best-seller, but I still wish the movie had used another title – something like “The Magic Jeans” or “4 Girls and a Pair of Levis” or anything else, for that matter.

Now that I’ve got that off my chest, let the praise begin. Amber Tamblyn, Alexis Bledel, Blake Lively and America Ferrera light up the screen as high school best friends who must part for the first time during one summer vacation. When they find a pair of jeans that fits each one of them perfectly, the girls decide to keep in touch by taking turns wearing the jeans, then sending them on to the next friend on the “traveling pants” list. This special article of clothing becomes a symbolic link for an unbreakable friendship, and these four beguiling young actresses do a terrific job of showing how much their characters care about each other.

Only one of the girls stays home during the summer in question. Tibby, played by Tamblyn (“Joan of Arcadia”) is a cynical rebel who stocks the shelves at a local store while trying to make a documentary (which she calls a “suckumentary”). What an expressive face Tamblyn has! She projects so much heartbreaking emotion with those soulful eyes, especially when dealing with disturbing news about her self-appointed filmmaking assistant (Jenna Boyd, a delightful scenestealer). I think an entire movie could be made about these two fascinating youngsters.

Carmen, portrayed by Ferrera (“Real Girls Have Curves”) spends part of the summer trying to get better acquainted with her dad (Bradley Whitford) who left his wife and child several years earlier. However, standing in her way are the dad’s wedding plans and his potential new family. Carmen is probably the most difficult role in this film, but Ferrera manages to carry it off by emerging as a volatile bundle of anger ready to erupt at all the wrong moments.

Newcomer Lively makes an impressive motion picture debut as Bridget, who uses her athletic skill like a shield against the sadness she feels about her mom’s suicide. Bridget spends her summer at a soccer camp in Mexico and falls for one of the coaches, which, of course, is against the rules. With her strong physical stature and vibrant screen charisma, Lively reminds me of Daryl Hannah at the beginning of her movie career.

Finally, there’s Lena – portrayed with birdlike delicacy by Bledel (“The Gilmore Girls”) -- a shy artist who discovers her true self through the ups and downs of a romantic adventure while visiting her grandparents in Greece. Bledel’s youthful loveliness almost outshines the visual splendor of Santorini, the Greek island photographed so gloriously by John Bailey (“Divine Secrets of the Ya Ya Sisterhood”).

Director Ken Kwapis (“He Said, She Said”) deserves credit for steering away from anything sappy or cute and for “making sure the voices and intention of Ann Brashares’ story were vividly preserved from book to screen.” Fortunately, Kwapis had expert help from screenwriters Delia Ephron (“You’ve Got Mail”) and Elizabeth Chandler (“What a Girl Wants”).

How does author Brashares feel about the finished product? She reports being happy that the filmmakers depicted her characters as she envisioned them – “with warts and all” – and that they avoided the temptation to wrap things up neatly. “I never want to tell a story that’s leading up to a lesson learned,” Brashares says. “If that’s what’s drawing you through a story then you’re not listening to the characters the way you need to. In life, not everything is resolved.”

Everything may not be resolved in “The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants," but at least one thing comes through with stunning clarity – the importance of having good friends you can count on at any age.



Betty Jo Tucker

If the title causes your stomach to rumble, stay away. Because it's exactly what you think: a girly drama about friendship, coming of age and coming to terms. Plus a magical pair of jeans. We're in trouble from the start, and the filmmakers never even try to avoid the inevitable sludge.

For four 17-year-old friends, this'll be their first summer apart. So when they find a pair of jeans that mysteriously fits them all, they decide to share them over the summer. Lena (Bledel) visits her grandparents on a Greek island, where she meets cute young fisherman Kostas (Rady). Carmen (Ferrera) stays with her dad (Whitford) and is surprised by his new fiancee (Travis) and stepkids. Bridget (Lively) goes to soccer camp in Mexico and falls for her coach (Vogel). And Tibby (Tamblyn) stays home, reluctantly befriending a secretive young girl (Boyd).

Yes, the jeans are a symbol of self-confidence, connectedness, whatever. The girls must make decisions on their own, grow up, face the realities of their families, realise the importance of friendship. This isn't a bad concept, but the film is far too slick and soulless-- over-staged, over-written, over-cute, overwrought. It's also deeply condescending, explaining everything in detail (cue another pants-in-the-post montage) just to make sure 10-year-old girls, who will make up the film's fanbase, can follow it. But even 10-year-olds aren't that stupid!

Fortunately, the actresses breathe life into their roles. Bledel and Lively have the cliched forbidden-love storylines, and struggle to find anything original. But Ferrera finds emotional resonance as a teenager terrified that she might be losing her father forever, especially when she finally confronts him about it. And Tamblyn has the film's most inventive journey, as well as the spikiest character, even if her plot thread turns the most maudlin.

But then the filmmakers just can't resist sentiment, and seem happy to wallow in corny humour, predictable sappiness and heavy-handed moralising. For viewers who enjoy this kind of thing, it's a well-made film that will connect on various levels. Bring a box of tissues. Everyone else should keep an air-sick bag handy.

Rich Cline

Site Contents Copyright© The Z Review, unless used with permission.This site has no intention to infringe on the rights of the film owners of The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants and intellectual copyright holders of the movies mentioned herein & hold copyright over the movie, characters, merchandise & storyline.