Films
about people trying to make it big in show-biz usually fascinate
me. I loved every version of “A Star Is Born”
ever made, but especially the one starring Judy Garland.
So, naturally, I looked forward to seeing “Undiscovered,”
a movie about a young musician struggling to be noticed
in the big city of Los Angeles. And, because of newcomer
Steven Strait’s fine supporting work as Warren Peace
in “Sky High,” I was eager to see him in a leading
role.
This
guy appears to have it all – looks, talent, charisma
– and a smile to die for. But just like the character
he plays in “Undiscovered,” his trip to stardom
may crash. The reason? He’s stuck in a movie so bad
it makes “The Perfect Man” seem Shakespearean
in comparison. It would be a shame if such a disaster happened
to Strait. He reminds me of a young Marlon Brando -- plus
he can sing with emotional as well as physical power. And
his character emerges as the only continuously watchable
one here.
"Undiscovered"
manages to contain every romantic cliché in the book:
meeting cute; being separated; the let’s-be-friends-not-lovers
phase; falling in love anyway; breaking up; and finally,
getting together in a crowd-pleasing clinch at the end.
Why doesn’t this tried-and-true approach work here?
Too much talking about everything, a less than convincing
performance by lovely leading lady Pell James ("Uptown
Girls"), and jerky camera movements that make it difficult
to get involved with what’s happening on screen. A
similar romantic story played out much better in “A
Lot Like Love,“ which was released earlier this year
and is now available on DVD.
Supporting
cast members Kip Pardue (“Imaginary Heroes”),
Shannyn Sossamon (“A Knight’s Tale”),
and Carrie Fisher (“Star Wars”) have all been
better in other films. I had trouble accepting Pardue as
Strait’s concerned brother; Sossamon adopts a sexy
but hard-to-understand Brazilian accent; and the usually
wonderful Fisher comes across as too blasé for her
modern fairy godmother-type role.
Although
some of the musical sequences liven up the movie, they’re
few and far between. However, I’m pleasantly surprised
at how much I enjoyed Ashlee Simpson’s last vocal
number. She plays a good friend to the leading couple who
ultimately shows what she can do on stage by singing the
film's title song.
While
exploring the fleeting nature of fame, "Undiscovered"
makes a good point about the value of creativity over celebrity
status. “Creativity is passion and it’s endless,”
says Peter Weller’s ("The Order") wise character
to a musician who really wants to write songs, not perform
them.
Here’s
hoping Steve Strait gets the chance to display HIS creativity
and passion in many future movies.